Due to efficient drainage of the joint, the development of intra-articular depots for long-lasting drug release is a difficult challenge. Moreover, a disease-modifying osteoarthritis drug (DMOAD) that can effectively manage osteoarthritis has yet to be identified. The current study was undertaken to explore the potential of injectable, in situ forming implants to create depots that support the sustained release of punicalagin, a promising DMOAD. In vitro experiments demonstrated punicalagin’s ability to suppress production of interleukin-1β and prostaglandin E2, confirming its chondroprotective properties. Regarding the entrapment of punicalagin, it was demonstrated by LC-MS/MS to be stable within PLGA in situ forming implants for several weeks and capable of inhibiting collagenase upon release. In vitro punicalagin release kinetics were tunable through variation of solvent, PLGA lactide:glycolide ratio, and polymer concentration, and an optimized formulation supported release for approximately 90 days. The injection force of this formulation steadily increased with plunger advancement and higher rates of advancement were associated with greater forces. Although the optimal formulation was highly cytotoxic to primary chondrocytes if cells were exposed immediately or shortly after implant formation, upwards of 70 % survival was achieved when the implants were first allowed to undergo a 24–72 h period of phase inversion prior to cell exposure. This study demonstrates a PLGA-based in situ forming implant for the controlled release of punicalagin. With modification to address cytotoxicity, such an implant may be suitable as an intra-articular therapy for OA.